Samuel Hahnemann was a good guy

I’ve been following progress on “Blogging the Organon” , which at the time or writing has got to Paragraph 36 of the Organon – the principal work of the founder of homeopathy. Viewed as a historical document, it’s quite interesting.

First of all, you’ve got to put it in context. The Organon was published in 1810, when very little of modern medical science existed. William Harvey had demonstrated the circulation of blood in 1628. Edward Jenner (1796) had discovered the potential of vaccination with (mild) cowpox to prevent the (worse) disease of smallpox. However there was no understanding of its underlying mechanism – this was moved forward significantly by Louis Pasteur (1885), well after Hahnemann’s death. The germ theory of disease evolved in the 1850’s; Darwin published on evolution in 1859, and Mendel on inheritance in 1865.

It would be fair to say that in 1810, medical science was still in its infancy.

Hanhemann was well acquainted with the medical science of his day, and in the initial chapters he trashes much of it – probably with good justification. However he acknowledges the importance of surgery, of vaccination, and of basic procedures such as the removal of foreign bodies, parasites, and toxic agents – it’s a pity he didn’t know about bacteria.

He goes on to create what is – basically – a theory of “everything else”, which was the foundation of homeopathy. It postulates, among other things, that an invisible entity called a “miasm” causes disease, and that there is a divinely ordained symmetry between the symptoms of a disease and the indications of the substance which can cure it. He very carefully crafts his theory so that it doesn’t conflict with established medical practice.

And here the clock stops, as far as present day homeopaths are concerned – homeopathy does not seem to have moved on, or to have learned from developments in evidence based medicine in the subsequent two centuries. Homeopaths still seem to believe that modern doctors prescribe in much the same random way as their antecedents did in 1810; they don’t accept that bacteria can cause disease, and they have a completely bizarre and somewhat fatalistic approach to serious disease.

Would Samuel Hanhemann approve of this? He was an intelligent man, independent thinking and a pragmatist. He’s probably turning in his grave.

 

About these ads

Tags: , , ,

5 Responses to “Samuel Hahnemann was a good guy”

  1. homeopathy4health Says:

    Homeopathy has developed in its own way with further thoughts on miasms (or taints might be a better word) disease ‘state’ and remedy families by Rajan Sankaran, on mineral remedies by Jan Scholten and much filling in of the gaps in available remedies by these homeopaths and others such as Vermeulen. Also a much larger repertory by the work of Schroyens.

  2. mugsandmoney Says:

    …….. which, I think, confirms my point about homeopathy not being informed by developments in evidence based medicine. Thank you.

  3. homeopathy4health Says:

    You’re welcome. But it hasn’t stood still either.

  4. jdc325 Says:

    Blogging the Organon has provided a few gems. I liked this one, in response to a homeopath contradicting themselves (by going from “Psychiatric patients do not get acute diseases because they are too ill already” to “it is not accurate to say that psychiatric patients NEVER suffer from acute illness”) –

    Basically people suffering chronic disease do not succumb to acute disease, except for when they do. I take everything back, homeopaths make perfect sense

  5. She-Liger Says:

    Aha! Good…
    Like E. Ernst! :(
    http://postpostscripti.wordpress.com

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s


Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

%d bloggers like this: